Food & Drink
Sukiyaki and Shabu-shabu
すき焼き・しゃぶしゃぶすきやき・しゃぶしゃぶsukiyaki, shabushabuThinly sliced beef, cooked at the table two ways
Sukiyaki and shabu-shabu are tabletop dishes of thinly sliced beef cooked at the table. In sukiyaki the meat is cooked in a sweet soy-based sauce and dipped in raw egg; in shabu-shabu it is swished briefly through simmering broth and dipped in sesame or ponzu sauce.
For more than a thousand years, meat from four-legged animals was officially shunned in Japan under Buddhist influence, although game was eaten under euphemistic names. When the ports opened in the 1850s and Western customs arrived in the Meiji period, eating beef became a symbol of modernity. Gyūnabe, beef simmered in a pan with miso or soy sauce, was the fashionable dish of Yokohama and Tokyo, and it developed into sukiyaki.
Shabu-shabu is much younger. It was developed after the Second World War from a Chinese hot pot of mutton, and a restaurant in Osaka is credited with giving it its name in the 1950s, from the swishing sound the meat makes in the broth. Both dishes are now typical meals for celebrations, family gatherings and entertaining guests, and a showcase for high-grade wagyu.
Sukiyaki
Sukiyaki is cooked in a shallow cast-iron pan at the table. Two regional methods exist. In the Kantō style, the ingredients are simmered in warishita, a ready-mixed sauce of soy sauce, mirin, sugar and sake or dashi. In the Kansai style, beef fat is melted in the pan, the beef is seared, and sugar and soy sauce are added directly, before the vegetables go in.
Typical ingredients besides beef are grilled tofu (yaki-dōfu), long green onion, shungiku (chrysanthemum greens), shiitake, shirataki noodles and sometimes wheat gluten (fu). Each bite is dipped in beaten raw egg, which cools and softens the rich, sweet flavour. Udon noodles are often added to the remaining sauce at the end.
Warishita
割下warishitaThe premixed sukiyaki sauce used in the Kantō style.
- 牛鍋gyūnabe
Meiji-era beef hot pot, the forerunner of sukiyaki; still served in Yokohama.
Shirataki
しらたきshiratakiTranslucent noodles made from konnyaku (devil's tongue).
Shungiku
春菊shungikuEdible chrysanthemum greens with a slightly bitter aroma.
Shabu-shabu
Shabu-shabu is cooked in a pot of lightly flavoured broth, often simply water with kombu. Each diner lifts a slice of meat with chopsticks and swishes it through the simmering broth for a few seconds until it changes colour, then dips it in sauce. Vegetables, tofu and mushrooms are cooked in the same broth, which gradually becomes richer; at the end it may be seasoned and eaten with rice or noodles.
The dish uses very thin slices, usually of marbled beef, but pork shabu-shabu is at least as common at home. Variants use duck, yellowtail (buri shabu) or octopus.
Goma-dare
胡麻だれgoma-dareCreamy sesame dipping sauce, usually for meat.
- ポン酢ponzu
Citrus and soy sauce, usually for vegetables and tofu.
- ぶりしゃぶburi shabu
Yellowtail shabu-shabu, a winter speciality of the Sea of Japan coast, notably Toyama.
Butashabu
豚しゃぶbutashabuPork shabu-shabu, common at home and also eaten cold as a salad in summer.
Beef and wagyu
Both dishes are a traditional way to enjoy high-grade beef. Butchers and supermarkets sell beef sliced specifically for each: slightly thicker for sukiyaki, paper-thin for shabu-shabu. Well-marbled cuts from wagyu breeds, such as the shoulder loin and sirloin, are particularly prized because the fat melts at low temperatures.
Well-known beef regions including Matsusaka in Mie, Kobe in Hyogo and Ōmi in Shiga are closely associated with sukiyaki, and many long-established sukiyaki houses date from the Meiji period.
- 松阪牛Matsusaka-ushi
Premium wagyu from the Matsusaka area of Mie Prefecture.
- 近江牛Ōmi-ushi
Wagyu from Shiga Prefecture, one of the oldest beef brands in Japan.
- 神戸ビーフKōbe bīfu
Certified Tajima-line beef from Hyogo Prefecture.
At the table
In restaurants, a server often cooks the first portion of sukiyaki and demonstrates the method; diners then continue themselves. At home, one person tends the pot, adding ingredients and adjusting heat. Separate serving chopsticks are sometimes used for raw meat.
For shabu-shabu, meat is best cooked a slice at a time and eaten immediately rather than left in the pot. Skimming the foam (aku) from the broth keeps it clear.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between sukiyaki and shabu-shabu?
Sukiyaki is simmered in a sweet soy-based sauce and dipped in raw egg; shabu-shabu is cooked briefly in plain broth and dipped in sesame or ponzu sauce. Sukiyaki tastes rich and sweet, shabu-shabu light.
Is it safe to eat the raw egg in sukiyaki?
Eggs sold in Japan are produced and dated for eating raw, and raw egg with sukiyaki is standard. Anyone who prefers can ask for the egg to be left out.
Where does the name shabu-shabu come from?
It imitates the sound of the meat being swished through the broth. The name dates from the 1950s in Osaka.
Why is sukiyaki called sukiyaki?
The origin is uncertain. One common explanation links it to meat grilled on a spade (suki), another to thinly sliced (suki) meat.
Related
Sources
- 1.うちの郷土料理 (opens in a new tab) — 農林水産省 (Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries)
- 2.Japan National Tourism Organization – Official travel guide (opens in a new tab) — JNTO